Antennella aff. varians ( Billard, 1911 )

Galea, Horia R. & Maggioni, Davide, 2020, Plumularioid hydroids (Cnidaria: Hydrozoa) from off New Caledonia collected during KANACONO and KANADEEP expeditions of the French Tropical Deep-Sea Benthos Program, European Journal of Taxonomy 708, pp. 1-58 : 24-28

publication ID

publication LSID

persistent identifier

treatment provided by


scientific name

Antennella aff. varians ( Billard, 1911 )


Antennella aff. varians ( Billard, 1911)

Figs 11A View Fig , 12 View Fig A–C, 13A–B; Table 4

Plumularia varians Billard, 1911 : LXII, fig. 2.

Plumularia varians – Van Praët 1979: 930, fig. 72. Antennella varians – Billard 1913: 11, fig. 4, pl. 1 figs 5, 8. — Bedot 1917: 116, 124; 1921a: 5. —

Hirohito 1969: 24, fig. 17; 1983: 59; 1995: 238, fig. 79d–g. — Schuchert 1997 (pro parte): 32,

figs 10, 11e–g. — Di Camillo et al. 2008: 1592, 1595. — Ansín Agís et al. 2009: 36, fig. 1. Antenella varians – Ritchie 1913: 7. — Hirohito 1969: 24, fig. 17 (incorrect subsequent spelling).

non Antennella varians – Rees & Vervoort 1987: 117, fig. 23c–d. — Schuchert 1997 (pro parte): 35,

fig. 11a–d [= A ntennella balei ( Billard, 1911) ].

Material examined

PACIFIC OCEAN • 1 sterile colony, ca 10 cm high; off New Caledonia, stn CP4985; 20°49′ S, 160°57′ E; 480–540 m; 10 Sep. 2017; KANADEEP leg.; MNHN-IK-2015-603 GoogleMaps .

Additional material

BALI SEA • 1 sterile colony of Antennella balei ( Billard, 1911) , with stems up to 5 cm high; Indonesia, Bali Island ; 8°21′ S, 115°42′ E; 18.5 m; 30 Jan. 2017; HRG-1337 GoogleMaps .

CELEBES SEA • 1 sterile colony of true A. varians ( Billard, 1911) , with stems up to 3 cm high; Indonesia, Siladen Island ; 1°37′35.1″ N, 124°48′7.4″ E; 30–50 m; Jan. 2003; HRG-1584 GoogleMaps 1 fertile (monoecious) colony of A. balei ( Billard, 1911) , with stems up to 5.5 cm high; Indonesia, Derawan Archipelago, off Sangalaki Island ; 2°05′21″ N, 118°24′04″ E; 20 m; 23 Apr. 2010; HRG-0132 GoogleMaps .

FLORES SEA • 1 fertile (monoecious) colony of A. balei ( Billard, 1911) , with stems up to 6 cm high; Indonesia , Alor Archipelago , Ternate Island, off Biatabang; 8°13′26″ S, 124°21′53″ E; 15 m; 21 Oct. 2010; HRG-0546 GoogleMaps .


Colony upright, ca 10 cm high, arising from elongated (2–3 cm high) mass of interlacing hydrorhizal fibers anchoring it in sediment, giving rise from its upper part to bundle of individual hydrocladia, all pointing upwards. Cladia up to 6 cm high, composed proximally of up to 1.5 cm long ahydrothecate part with two closely-set, parallel rows of frontal nematothecae, placed mostly alternately, occasionally in opposite pairs; ahydrothecate part ending in deeply-incised, oblique node, separated from remainder of cladium through prosegment, the latter also ending distally in oblique node; prosegment with hydrotheca and its five associated nematothecae (a mesial one and two pairs of laterals), as well as four additional nematothecae imperceptibly displaced laterally, left and right, along longitudinal axis of internode. Remainder of hydrocladium undivided, but equivalents of internodes with hydrotheca, its four associated nematothecae (two pairs of laterals), as well as row of 2–4 nematothecae above (commonly 3, but proximal ‘internodes’ with 4 of these, and distal ‘internodes’ with only 2). Hydrotheca cup-shaped, fully adnate, abaxial wall straight for most of its length, slightly curved inwardly at aperture; rim smooth, aperture circular, facing upwards. All nematothecae bithalamic and movable; mesial nematotheca indistinguishable morphologically from its counterparts situated proximally in row, all with slightly scooped rim of upper chamber; lateral nematothecae in pairs, first pair borne on tips of moderately-developed apophyses, second pair seated near bases of same apophyses; first pair greatly surpassing hydrothecal rim, with tall basal chamber, upper chamber shallow, conical, with rim entire; second pair comparatively shorter, wall of upper chamber scooped on adaxial side. Gonothecae absent.


There is little doubt that the present material is conspecific with that described and illustrated earlier by Ansín Agís et al. (2009). Both display a single row of nematothecae between successive hydrothecae (except for the proximalmost internodes), and this represents a deviation from the current concept of A. varians ( Billard, 1911) , in which the nematothecae are arranged in two parallel rows, even though their distribution in pairs is not always met with ( Billard 1913; present study).Additionally, a comparison of the material at hand with true specimens of A. varians from Indonesia (sample HRG-1584) reveals a series of discrete differences, such as the shape of the hydrotheca (compare Fig. 12 View Fig B–C and 12D–E, respectively) and the size of the anterior pair of lateral nematothecae (compare Fig. 13B and 13C View Fig ). Their morphometrical differences are summarized in Table 4. For these reasons, the New Caledonian material is provisionally assigned to the hydroid of Billard (1911), pending a more comprehensive morphological study based on a relevant number of colonies, as well as genetic data.

Billard (1913) distinguished his A. varians from A. balei ( Billard, 1911) on the following accounts: 1) the proximal part of the stems always bears a prosegment in the former, but never in the latter; its occurrence was documented by a number of authors (e.g., Billard 1913: fig. 4a; Hirohito 1995: fig. 79d;

present study); 2) the frontal pair of lateral nematothecae is borne on moderately-developed apophyses, unlike in A. balei where these apophyses are comparatively longer, stubby, and fused to the hydrothecal wall; 3) the anterior pair of lateral nematothecae is trumpet-shaped instead of being short and conical, and possesses wide apertures.

In spite of the opinion of Schuchert (1997), A. balei is here kept distinct from A.varians . Indeed, the examination of several samples from three distant localities in Indonesia reveals a uniformity of morphological characters: 1) although deeply-incised, strongly oblique nodes occur here and there along the stems, delimiting internodes with numerous hydrothecae, a prosegment is lacking in all specimens; 2) the proximal part of each stem (± 1 cm long) bears a varied number of hydrothecae until the first strongly oblique node occurs; in some specimens, this portion could be segmented by slightly oblique nodes into internode bearing irregularly 1, 2, 3, etc. hydrothecae; these nodes, although distinct, are neither that deeply-incised, nor that strongly oblique as the scarce nodes that occasionally divide the caulus above; 3) there is no single mesial nematotheca, even in the internodes immediately above a deeply-incised, strongly-oblique node; 4) there are generally 2 pairs (occasionally 3 proximally) of nematothecae in two parallel rows above each hydrotheca, the members of each pair being always situated at the same level; 5) a deeply-incised, strongly-oblique node generally passes through two consecutive pairs of stem nematothecae, one being confined to the internode below, the other to the internode above; 6) all nematothecae have a hypertrophied perisarc; the first pair of laterals is borne on long, horizontal apophyses fused to the lateral walls of the hydrotheca; the second pair is sessile, and the nematothecae have a size comparable to their anterior counterparts; the wall of the upper chamber of the anterior nematothecae is sinusoid on the adaxial side.

Antennella biarmata Nutting, 1927 is very likely a junior synonym of A. balei , judging from the shape and size of the apophysis supporting the lateral nematothecae, and additional characters mentioned in the original account.

The material assigned by Rees & Vervoort (1987) to A. varians could not be allocated with certainty to either A. varians or A. balei , due to an unusual segmentation of the stems and some characters displayed by the nematothecae.


Indonesia ( Billard 1913; Di Camillo et al. 2008), Japan ( Hirohito 1995), New Caledonia ( Ansín Agís et al. 2009; present study).














Antennella aff. varians ( Billard, 1911 )

Galea, Horia R. & Maggioni, Davide 2020

Antennella varians

Rees W. J. & Vervoort W. 1987: 117
Schuchert 1997 (pro parte): 35, fig. 11a–d [= A ntennella balei ( Billard, 1911 ) ].

Plumularia varians

Van Praet M. 1979: 930
Bedot M. 1917: 116
Billard A. 1913: 11
Hirohito 1969: 24 , fig. 17
Schuchert 1997 (pro parte): 32, figs 10, 11e–g. — Di Camillo et al. 2008: 1592 , 1595 . — Ansín Agís et al. 2009: 36 , fig. 1. Antenella varians – Ritchie 1913: 7 . — Hirohito 1969: 24 , fig. 17 (incorrect subsequent spelling).
Di Camillo et al. 2008: 1592 , 1595
Ansín Agís et al. 2009: 36 , fig. 1.
Ritchie 1913: 7
Hirohito 1969: 24 , fig. 17

Plumularia varians

Plumularia varians Billard, 1911 : LXII, fig. 2.

Antenella varians

Ritchie 1913: 7
Hirohito 1969: 24 , fig. 17